Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 

Time to get crackin!

Tue Mar 10, 2009, 9:45 AM
I had a great talk with a well known animation prop designer, Geoffrey Kater. he worked on such shows as "Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego?"as well as the silver surfer and many others. Apparently he is a friend of a friend of my mothers, and so I was passed down a chain and we arranged a phone call to just chat and for him to critique my work.

Oh man did he rip me a new one. It was something I had needed for a long time. I was stuck in an endless cycle of pats on the back and smiles with no one really giving it to me straight. He pointed out all my weaknesses and commented on my strengths. Weaknesses such as that I clearly draw women more than men, that my hands are pretty hit or miss (mostly miss) and that I usually feel pretty uncomfortable leaving my comfort zone. He pointed out strengths that I personally thought were weaknesses, such as my backgrounds and color, and the fact that, when appropriate I can adapt to different styles.

It was fantastic, and I felt so refreshed after wards. I think he was surprised that I took it all so well haha. I mean, 90% of the people I know cannot take a critique for anything, and I know even I will get defensive over my work sometimes (usually right after I think I may have finished it) but I was so happy to be getting honest unbiased feedback. I even took notes. So, from me, for a whie anyways, my work will probably be pretty terrible as I try and strengthen my weaknesses. I'll draw more hands, and better, I'll draw more men and boys and animals. I'll draw old people and young people and maybe even dead people.

On another unrelated note, Joe and I got a dog. Although, he's not really a dog so much as a cartoon of a dog. he has giant ears and is a total spazoid. His name is Jin, and I will most likely make drawings of him, as well as my evil cat Nero, and my retarded cat Nixi.

  • Mood: Lazy
  • Listening to: Linkin Park - In Between
  • Reading: The Joy Luck Club
  • Watching: Hana Yori Dango and Zettai Kareshi live actions &a
  • Playing: Sonic Unleashed...for some reason
  • Drinking: Milk!

Devious Comments

love 2 2 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconfrateroshi:
excellent news; good to here you getting motivated.

incidentally, my agent guy is looking to switch his studio over into a full-time production house and he needs animators who know After Effects. He's gonna try to train me, but if i'm too dense or he needs more, i'll be dropping your name. hope that's ok.

good luck with leaving your comfort zone. i'm actually more comfortable outside my comfort zone....so i guess it doesn't count. i'm confused now.
:icondamoser:
yeah, honest critiques are nice to get, as long as they're said in ways that are udbuilding. and hey, when you show us all the crap you're producing as you experiment out of your comfort zone, don't you worry, i'll be here to give the supportive "WTF?!?!? scrap it, that sucks!! *gags*"

--
[link]
:iconluvcnkll:
I'm so jealous. I'm also afraid. I feel a critique is intimate and receiving one from a stranger, albeit a famous stranger, feels like rape. I need a good critiquing. I feel like I've hit a wall lately on my growth. It might have to do with not drawing as much...

If you're ever in my city drop a line. I'd love to see you. And good luck in everything in the meantime!

--
If you stop drawing your mom will say, "I told you so."
:iconkalicodreamz:
YOU MAKE NO SENSE!

But id I remember correctly, it's why we love ya.

PLEASE drop my name. I don't think I can do customer service much longer. I want to rip my hair out. I'm actually beginning to miss after effects. I need to get back into it and do more puppet animations.
:iconkalicodreamz:
Yay!
I need it with all the "OMG TIS AWESOMEZ" that I get from AP. One reason why I am so unmotivated to wall.
So please feel free to rip it apart, even if it seems like it's something minimal. I know I have a lot of places to improve upon.
:iconkalicodreamz:
Hey now, your city is also still my city.
I've been missing it a bit lately (minus all the snow and crap. it's 77 down here right now). I hoe I can come up in the summer to visit and get me some good Chinese food, but I doubt it.

It was scary for me to get the critique because I'm always afraid that what I will have to work on will be too much for me to handle. I especially get freaked out when I see work from artist's like artgerm, who are just amazing. I always struggle with myself because I see someone else's drawings and I think "I wish I could do that..." and it ends up holding me back instead of pushing me forward for whatever reason. I need to become more comfortable with myself and how I draw.

Let me know if you ever want a good solid critique on anything. I'll be hoping to get some from you as I try and extend my comfort zone to include stuff other than women haha.
:iconluvcnkll:
Yeah I feel the same way. Ok, the next time I'm proud of something I'll talk to you about it.

--
If you stop drawing your mom will say, "I told you so."
:iconderkgs:
:slow:
I haven't been on dA very often.. my random reappearance has led me to your journal :paranoid: I've missed a lot as usual :noes:!!! Wow though, what a great opportunity! I'm really glad that you were able to meet with such a person :D

PS. Joy Luck Club... how nostalgic :giggle: --and wow, everyone around me is watching Hana Yori Dango :lol:

--
"If you immediately know the candlelight is fire, then the meal was cooked a long time ago."
:icondamoser:
only if you promise to return the favor, which would likely require you to write an essay for each piece of "art" you see from me.

--
[link]

Sponsored By Ninja Assassin

Journal History

Site Map